Monday, April 13, 2009

Group 5FD - Discussion Topic

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

yeah i agree

kelvin a said...

In chapters 17 and 18 music and talent shows played an important role such like in chapters before.
Do you think if Esther didn't give Ishmael the package with the Walkman and the cassette, would Ishmael have treated her diffrently?

Lady Fab said...

I DONT THINK ISHMAEL WOULD HAVE TREATED HER DIFFERENTLY BECAUSE THEY WERE STARTING TO GET TO KNOW EACH OTHER.SO SHE DID THAT OUT OF HER KINDNESS....

dannyboy12888 said...

Yes I think most likey wouldn't have opened up to her about his war stories.

Luis G. said...

I DONT THINK ISHMAEL WOULD HAVE TREATED HER DIFFERENTLY JUST FOR THE REASON NOW THEY TREAT EACH OTHER WITH SOME TYPE OF TRUST.

Anonymous said...

Yes i think ishmael would have treated her differently if she didnt reward him with the cassette because music was something besides break dancing he cherished his music. So yes i think ishmael would have treated her differently.

Anonymous said...

Yes Ishmael would of treated her differently because he cared more about his music nd break dancing more then anything..

nilkanth p said...

I don't think that Ishmael would have treated her differently because he needs a person to bond to so he could tell the person what he feels. I the she likes to him help out and make sure his life gets better that’s why I think she gave him the walkman.

LaTeafa201 said...

I believe he would treated her differently.

Chrisna Idawati said...

We don't know. But it might be Esther will find it more difficult to approach Ishmael. By giving him the walkman and cassette Esther didn't find any difficulties because music is really the thing that Ishmael loves a lot.

Anonymous said...

I think that Ishmael would have treated her different because the cassette and the walkman are the only thing from the past.

ramona said...

to nilkanth your response was thoughtful I do agree with your statement she wants to help Ishmael as best as she can

ramona said...

to lady fab your post was cincere, they were beginning to come close to one another, she was indeed a nice person